Gemini Gems vs Custom GPTs vs Claude Projects
Three ways to save a reusable assistant. As of October 2026, two of the three are being replaced, which changes the answer.
We have no affiliate deal with Google, OpenAI or Anthropic, and nobody paid to appear on this page.
What changed: OpenAI plans to retire custom GPTs in favor of plugins 6, and Google is converting Gems into skills 2. So the real comparison for new work is Claude Projects against ChatGPT Projects and Gemini skills. This page covers the old three and where each one is headed.
At a glance
| What you get | Gemini Gems | Custom GPTs | Claude Projects |
|---|---|---|---|
| Status | Moving to skills: personal accounts read-only 17 Nov 2026, removed 17 Dec; work Mar 2027, education Jun 2027 2 | Retiring 11 Dec 2026 6 | Active 12 |
| Who can create | Work and school accounts until Gems are retired; personal accounts can't create Gems since 17 Nov 2026 2 | Business, Enterprise and Edu workspaces only 5 | Every plan; Free up to 5 9 |
| What it holds | Name, instructions, knowledge files 1 | Instructions, knowledge, starters, tools, actions 5 | Instructions, knowledge, chats, its own memory 9 |
| Knowledge files | Upload, Google Drive (kept current) or Gemini Notebook, formerly NotebookLM 1 | Up to 20 files, 512 MB each 5 | 30 MB per file; total must fit the context window 10 |
| Built-in tools | Canvas, Deep Research, video and music creation 2 | Web search, images, Canvas, code, apps or actions 5 | Project memory; skills add procedures on demand 11 |
| Sharing | Like a Drive file in Workspace; recipients can edit, use or copy 4 | Options vary by account and workspace 5 | Team and Enterprise only; view or edit 9 |
| Replaced by | Gemini skills 2 | ChatGPT plugins 7 | Nothing; skills sit alongside 11 |
What you can put in each
All three start from the same idea: standing instructions plus reference files, so you stop pasting the same context into every chat. They differ in what else they carry.
A Gem is the lightest. You give it a name and instructions and, optionally, knowledge files 1. Google also ships premade Gems such as a Learning coach. Gems cannot be used in Gemini Live.
A custom GPT is the most configurable. Beyond instructions and knowledge, it has a public-facing name, description and conversation starters, a recommended model, switchable capabilities, and actions that call external APIs. A GPT can use apps or actions, but not both at once 5.
A Claude Project is a workspace more than a bot. It holds project instructions, knowledge files and every chat you have in it, and it keeps its own memory. Project chats can also use your account memory unless you turn off Use account memory 9. The name and description are for you; Claude does not see them.
The instructions you write transfer between all three. Here is a recurring email assistant you can paste into any of them:
You are my executive assistant for client email. Write in a concise, confident tone, no more than 120 words per reply. My goal is to close open requests fast, so every reply ends with one clear next step and a date. If the thread is missing information you need, list your questions instead of guessing. Use the attached style guide for sign-offs and formatting.
Sharing with your team
Gems in Workspace today; ChatGPT Projects on a budgetClaude Projects can be shared only on Team and Enterprise plans. You add colleagues by name or email as Can view or Can edit, and admins can switch sharing off 9. Team starts at two members, at $25 a seat or $20 billed yearly 13.
Gems share like Drive files in Google Workspace, inside your organization and beyond if Drive settings allow. Recipients can edit, use or copy the Gem. A Gem is shareable only when its knowledge files were uploaded from a device or added from Drive 4. Skills can be shared too, with Viewer or Editor access, but only from the Gemini web app 3.
Custom GPTs have sharing options that depend on your account and workspace 5. Migration to a plugin does not carry those settings over: the new plugin starts private, and existing users do not get access automatically 6.
The cheapest way to share a reusable setup today is ChatGPT Projects. Project sharing works on every ChatGPT plan, Free included, with chat or edit access. Free allows 5 collaborators, Go and Plus 10, Pro 100 8. Shared projects use project-only memory, so they never see a member's personal context.
Files and knowledge
For a large, stable set of reference documents, Claude Projects is the strongest of the three. There is no fixed file count; each file can be up to 30 MB, and the total must fit Claude's context window 10. On paid plans, Claude switches to a retrieval mode when the knowledge nears that limit, so the project can hold more 9. Project content is also cached, so reusing it counts less against your usage limit 15.
Custom GPTs take up to 20 files of up to 512 MB each. OpenAI recommends using knowledge for reference material and keeping rules and tone in the instructions 5. When a GPT migrates, its knowledge files are copied into the plugin's reference files 6.
Gems have the best link to living documents. A file added from Google Drive stays current: Gemini uses its latest version, so edits flow into the Gem. That needs History on and Google Workspace connected 1. Gemini skills accept documents, spreadsheets and slides, including .docx, .xlsx and .pptx, but not legacy .doc, .xls or .ppt, audio, video or archives, and all files must total 100 MB or less 3.
Tip: before Google converts your Gems, re-save any legacy .doc, .xls or .ppt knowledge files as .docx, .xlsx, .pptx or PDF so they survive the move to skills.
Which one for recurring work
Use the one tied to the assistant you already pay for, and build on the format that is staying, not the one being retired.
If you use Claude: a Project
Claude ProjectsMake one project per client, product or recurring report. Our editors keep source documents and templates in a single Claude Project, which cut the time spent re-explaining background at the start of each writing session. Pair it with Claude skills for procedures you use everywhere, such as a report format: skills load only when a task needs them, while a project's context is always on 11. Skills are on every Claude plan, Free included. See How to use Claude for the setup steps.
If you use ChatGPT: Projects and plugins
Don't start a new GPTPersonal ChatGPT accounts, including Free, Go, Plus and Pro, can no longer create or publish new GPTs. Existing GPTs keep working until retirement 5. OpenAI has scheduled custom GPTs to retire on 11 December 2026, with a deferral to 11 February 2027 for approved Enterprise workspaces 6.
For context, use a ChatGPT Project. For reusable instructions, use a plugin: install Plugin Creator from the plugin directory and describe what you want 7. If you built a GPT, look for Migrate to plugin under My GPTs. The instructions become a skill and the files carry over, but the selected model and any custom actions do not 6.
If you use Gemini: skills
Gemini skillsOn personal Google accounts, Gems convert to skills automatically, with supported files; the Gems themselves turned read-only on 17 November 2026 and are removed on 17 December 2. Skills need you to be 18 or older. They work with Keep Activity off (the skills help page's name for the setting Google's Gems page calls History), though Google says features that need it, like Connected Apps, won't be available. Skills are called with / in any chat. You can combine several in one task 3. Up to 100 can be active at a time 2.
Two gaps to know about: Canvas, Deep Research, video and music creation and Guided learning do not work with skills yet, and skill chats have no page of their own 2. On Google Workspace business accounts, Gems keep working until March 2027, so teams have time to plan. Google's plan page lists skills, not Gems, on Gemini's free plan 14.
- Save the files.Open the Gem's Edit view, download each knowledge file, and put them in a folder named in lowercase with hyphens.
- Create the skill.Go to Customize, Skills, Create, Create manually, paste the Gem's name, description and instructions, and click Create.
- Add the files.Download the skill as a .zip, move its SKILL.md into your folder, then use Replace skill to upload the folder 2.
Questions people ask
Are Gemini Gems going away?
On personal Google accounts, yes: they turned read-only on 17 November 2026 and are removed on 17 December, replaced by skills. Workspace business, enterprise and nonprofit accounts follow in March 2027, and education accounts in June 2027.
Can I still create a custom GPT?
Not on a personal plan. Free, Go, Plus and Pro accounts cannot create or publish new GPTs. Business, Enterprise and Edu workspaces can where settings allow, though OpenAI set 26 October 2026 as the end of new GPT creation in affected Enterprise workspaces.
What replaces custom GPTs?
Plugins. A plugin bundles skills (reusable instructions) with connected apps. OpenAI's migration turns a GPT's instructions into a skill and copies its files, but custom actions must be rebuilt.
Can I share a Claude Project?
Only on Claude Team and Enterprise plans, with view or edit access. On Free, Pro and Max, projects are private to you.
What is the difference between a Claude Project and a Claude skill?
A project is standing background knowledge for one area of work, always loaded in its chats. A skill is a saved procedure that Claude loads only when a task calls for it, in any chat.
Related
The next model change, in your inbox
195,000 readers get Uncover AI's practical AI briefing. We tell you what changed and whether it changes your pick.
Sources
- Use Gems in Gemini Apps
- About the transition from Gems to skills
- Create and manage skills for Gemini Apps
- Google Workspace Updates: Gem sharing
- Creating and editing GPTs
- Custom GPT retirement and migration FAQ
- Plugins in ChatGPT
- Projects in ChatGPT
- Claude: create and manage projects
- Upload files to Claude
- What are skills? (Claude)
- Claude pricing
- What is the Claude Team plan?
- Google AI plans (US)
- Claude usage limit best practices